Welcome to one of South Rochester's most sought-after neighborhoods! This classic garrison style home at 25 Tingley Street checks every box - and then some! Step inside from the charming front entry and you'll instantly feel the warmth this property exudes. A charming yet modern open-concept kitchen with newer appliances abuts an eat-in kitchen area on one side and a formal dining room on the other. For wonderful versatility, you can step down into the cozy family room off the eat-in area complete with a very efficient pellet stove and beautiful hearth. Or, enjoy the sun-filled, large front living room for gathering. Upstairs there are 4 well-appointed bedrooms, a primary en-suite 3/4 bathroom and full hallway bathroom, plus the finished lower level provides the perfect bonus space for a media room, home office, or play area. Outside, the extra-large lot is an entertainer's dream - featuring a paved mini basketball court to the side, two sheds, and a fenced-in yard that includes a nicely finished above-ground pool with deck, plus the peaceful privacy of wooded conservation land right in your backyard. Whether you're shooting hoops, floating in the pool, or simply enjoying sitting around the fire pit on the patio, this backyard delivers all the fun. Plus with the roof, premium Buderus boiler and hot water tank all under 5 years old -and public water and sewer - this home is ready for you to move in and simply enjoy!